More than 2000 years ago, the Greek philosopher Aristotle described the migration of bluefin tuna in the Mediterranean. Already in the Roman Empire tuna fishing was one of the most stable industries. This fishery, one of the most profitable in the world, is now threatened by industrial practices and lack of protection.
In 1999, we published a report highlighting the depletion of the
bluefin tuna population in the Mediterranean Sea. The biomass of adult
bluefin tuna - the spawning stock - had decreased 80 percent over
the previous 20 years. Every year, far too many juvenile tuna were
being caught, and pirate fleets were depleting the stock. Clearly,
drastic measures were needed to restore the bluefin tuna population.
Tuna ranching: a recipe for disaster
Sadly, since then, not only has the overfishing worsened, but a new
industrial activity targeting tuna is posing an added threat to the
survival of tuna in the Mediterranean. This is the capture, transport
and fattening of tuna in cages all along the Mediterranean coast
known as “tuna ranching”. Industrial purse seiners and tugboats sweep
the whole region in search of tuna, assisted by a flotilla of aircraft
and helicopters able to find schools of tuna, despite their dwindling
numbers.
Tuna ranching is a highly profitable activity directed at the Japanese
market. Instead of reducing fishing to help tuna recover in the
Mediterranean, fast profits have brought more money into the fishery:
this means new and bigger fishing boats, storage plants, and even new
airports to export the tuna. Governments have greatly contributed to
boost this expansion: European Union subsidies, as high as US$34 million
since 1997, coupled with big investments from Japan and Australia, have
encouraged even greater catches.
The practice has resulted in an increase in the catch of juvenile tuna,
and exacerbated the management difficulties faced by ICCAT (conservation body for the Atlantic tuna stock). No
one knows the actual amount of bluefin tuna caught in the Mediterranean
Sea, but it is clearly higher than the total allowable catch .
Tuna farming
The huge quantity of fish needed to feed farmed tuna is also a problem.
Up to 20 kgs of bait, made from fish, is used to produce just one
kilogram of tuna. An estimated 225,000 tonnes of bait are thrown every
year to the Mediterranean Sea, most coming from West Africa, the North
Atlantic and America. A recent report has highlighted the risk of
introducing diseases to local fish species from the fish bait, as has
previously occurred in tuna fattening operations in Australia. The
spread of disease to important local fish stocks such as anchovy or
sardine could be disastrous for local fishermen. From a precautionary
point of view, this risk is unacceptable.
Dolphin safe?
The demand for fish bait is also making fishermen harvest species that
were not previously fished commercially. This is the case of round
sardinella in the Alboran Sea, where increasing fishing for this
species may put at risk one of the healthiest common dolphin
populations in the Mediterranean.
Tuna ranching in the Mediterranean means that a previously common
resource shared by fishing cultures all around the Mediterranean Sea is
now controlled by a few investors. Not only is the bluefin tuna being
privatised and over-exploited, but other fisheries of the region are
also being placed in jeopardy.